Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Dariusz Jacek Jakóbczak, Koszalin University of Technology, Poland.

Reviewers:

(1) Saurabh Kumar, USA.

(2) Waffo Kemgne Martin, La Rochelle University, France.

(3) Mehdi Badrian, Islamic Azad University, Iran.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.5+8+8+6=30.5/4=7.625

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Saurabh Kumar, USA) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Waffo Kemgne Martin, France) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Mehdi Badrian, Iran) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Roxana Plesa, University of Petrosani, Romania.

Reviewers:

(1) Muhammad Faisal, Pakistan.

(2) Mamta Sharma, India.

(3) Miki Runtev, Republic of North Macedonia.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Miki, Macedonia.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.2/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Muhammad Faisal, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Mamta Sharma, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Miki Runtev, Republic of North Macedonia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Dariusz Jacek Jakóbczak, Koszalin University of Technology, Poland.

(2) Dr. Xi-Lan Liu, Qinghai Nationalities University, Xining, China.

Reviewers:

(1) R. Manimaran, SRM Institute of Science and Technology, India.

(2) Gaurav Kumar, KL University, India.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (R. Manimaran, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Gaurav Kumar, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Xi-Lan Liu, Qinghai Nationalities University, Xining, China.

(2) Dr. Dariusz Jacek Jakóbczak, Koszalin University of Technology, Poland.

Reviewers:

(1) Najmuddin Ahmad, Integral University Lucknow, India.

(2) Prabakaran Raghavendran, Vel Tech Rangarajan Dr. Sagunthala R&D Institute of Science and Technology, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Ahmed A. Hamoud, Taiz University, Yemen.

(2) Channveerapala Steesha, Government First Grade College, India.

(3) Khalid Mindeel Mohammed Al abrahemee, University of Al-Qadisiyah, Iraq.

(4) Muthuselvan. K, Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Najmuddin Ahmad, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Prabakaran Raghavendran, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Ridzwan Che Rus, Universiti  Pendidikan Sultan Idris, Malaysia.

Reviewers:

(1) Aris Sarjito, Republic of Indonesia Defense University, Indonesia.

(2) Muzaffar Syah Mallow, Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia (USIM), Malaysia.

(3) Trisnowati Rahayu, Politeknik Pelayaran Surabaya, Indonesia.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Müge Algan, World Peace University, Türkiye.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.16/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Aris Sarjito, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Muzaffar Syah Mallow, Malaysia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Trisnowati Rahayu, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Sherin Ahmed Mohamed Sherif, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt.

Reviewers:

(1) Madelyn N. Nay-ud, Ifugao State University, Philippines.

(2) Beatrice Atta Mensah, Accra Technical University, Ghana.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.6/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Madelyn N. Nay-ud, Philippines) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Beatrice Atta Mensah, Ghana) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Aleksandr Nikolaevich Sekisov, Kuban State Agrarian University, Russia.

Reviewers:

(1) Mira Falatifah, Matana University, Indonesia.

(2) Xuan Feng,EDHEC Business School, France.

(3) Suraj E S , KCT Business School, India.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.16/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Mira Falatifah, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Xuan Feng, France) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Suraj E S, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Fang Xiang, University of International and Business Economics, China.

(2) Dr. Rakesh Verma, AKTU Lucknow University, India.

Reviewers:

(1) A. Kamaruniza, University of Madras, India.

(2) Ricky Chia Chee Jiun, Universiti Malaysia Sabah, Malaysia.

(3) Raden Parianom, Universitas Pembangunan Nasional Veteran Jakarta, Indonesia.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) khaleel Radhi Hasan Alzlzly, Iraq.

(2) Owolabi Adesegun, Nigeria.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.1/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (A. Kamaruniza, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Ricky Chia Chee Jiun, Malaysia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Raden Parianom, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Roxana Plesa, University of Petrosani, Romania.

Reviewers:

(1) Jejeniwa Temitayo Oluwaseun, NASRDA, Nigeria.

(2) Shyam Maharjan, Kathmandu Bernhardt College, Nepal.

(3) Sonam wangmo , Gedu College of Business Studies, Bhutan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Subata Zannat Riya, Florida Atlantic University, United States of America.

(2) Tekalign Negash Kebede, Hawassa University, Hawassa, Ethiopia.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.43/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Jejeniwa Temitayo Oluwaseun, Nigeria) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Shyam Maharjan, Nepal) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Sonam wangmo, Bhutan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Sheng Zhang, Bohai University, China.

(2) Dr. Leo Willyanto Santoso, Petra Christian University, Indonesia.

Reviewers:

(1) A. Rajkumar, Bharathidasan University , India.

(2) N. Ramya, Kongu Engineering College, India.

(3) S Venkata Rao, Shri Vishnu Engineering College for Women(A), India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Ashok Sahebrao Mhaske, R. B. Narayanrao Borawake College, Savitribai Phule Pune University, India.

(2) M. Priyadharshini, Avinashilingam Institute for Home Science and Higher Education for Women, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.83/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (A. Rajkumar, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (N. Ramya, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (S Venkata Rao, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA